Timeline / 2 linked reports
Federal judge rules Oklahoma Flock search unconstitutional
This timeline contains reports linked by the NOISE desk. Automatic links follow a check of each report and its sources. It does not include all coverage of the subject.
-
Report 1
Federal judge rules Oklahoma Flock search unconstitutional
A federal judge in Oklahoma ruled Thursday that a deputy’s warrantless Flock Safety license-plate query violated Melisa Kyle’s Fourth Amendment rights and ordered all Flock evidence and evidence from her car search suppressed. Judge Sara Hill said Freddie Alaniz searched for Kyle’s plate solely because it was from California, then used more than 50 records of her monthlong movements across the country to justify searching her vehicle, which contained 91 pounds of meth, and called the network a form of indiscriminate mass surveillance. The nonbinding decision could inform other challenges to the technology, which audit logs viewed by 404 Media show receives more than 100,000 warrantless searches a month, and Flock said it expects an appeal and reversal.
From Evening NOISE.
-
Report 2
Federal judge rules warrantless Flock search violated Fourth Amendment
A federal judge ruled that a Tulsa, Oklahoma sheriff’s deputy violated a woman’s Fourth Amendment rights by using Flock Safety to search her license plate without a warrant. Judge Sara Hill said the deputy had no apparent reason for the search beyond the car’s California plate and ordered evidence discovered afterward, including 91 pounds of alleged methamphetamines, suppressed. Although the ruling does not establish binding precedent, it is among the first decisions to describe warrantless Flock searches as indiscriminate mass surveillance. Florida and Texas have said they will stop using the technology, while Sen. Bernie Sanders introduced a bill on Friday that would bar federal agencies from using automated license plate readers.
From Evening NOISE.